That attitude you have is called Deism, and it is what half of the founders of American had. They were in your camp and against the ‘war on atheism.’ Galileo and Newton propelled the deist belief system that underlay the Age of Enlightenment. Such deists like Franklin, Paine, Ethan Allen, and Jefferson were not fundamentalist Christians, a moment that was deliberately born in the South in the 1830 when the rich planters paid their own traveling preachers to come up with a moral sounding version of Christianity to counteract the revivalism—and “abolitionist”—traveling preachers invading the south and preaching to whites and blacks alike.
The Founders would be agree and be proud of you. Curiosity, ignorance and doubt lead to the use of deductive reasoning and weighing empirical evidence by the individual to come to her/his own conclusions about the existence of God, what kind of God, or gods, etc. You can’t dictate an individual’s beliefs, though the type of evangelical baptist preaching constructed to crush the message of abolitionist tried and tired. It seems they were victorious by the idea that atheists, agnostics, Jews, or Muslims can’t in American celebrate Christmas. These Christian nationalist beliefs spreading out from the South, constructed by slave owners to hang on to wealth would have sickened them.